Price transparency is making the life of European installers more difficult
In our daily lives, we are more and more used to check prices online prior to making a purchases. The possibilities to check prices online and the share amount of online stores have taken price transparency to the next level. Obviously, this has impacted the fast moving consumer goods market. But to what degree does this also effect the day-to-day business of the mechanical installers? Now obviously, they also have the ability to check prices online and order at online stores in order to get the best prices and thus increase their margins. However, from previous researches on buying behaviour we know that installers, a very traditional target group in a very traditional market, still a quite loyal to the traditional wholesale.
But this works the other way around as well. When providing a quote, end users and consumers have the opportunity to check the prices of the products and confront the installers with lower prices found online. Now let’s explore to what degree this happens and how much of an impact this has.
60% of European mechanical installers need to negotiate prices with end-users
As already suggested by the title of this article, European installers are often confronted with end users checking the prices of the products listed in the quote online. And this behaviour has been increasing. A whopping two thirds of all European mechanical installers are forced to negotiate prices with their end-users due to online price checking by end-users. This is one of the outcomes of the new Q3 2020 report on decision making in the mechanical installation market from the European Mechanical Installation Monitor by USP Marketing Consultancy.
Dutch end-users are most likely to check prices online and negotiate prices
In the Netherlands, a staggering 70% of all mechanical installers need to negotiate prices with end-users due to them having checked the prices online. This is the highest in all European countries. Now this is partly due to the high level of digitalisation of the Dutch society and of course the availability of prices of products to be found online. It might also be a cultural trait inherent to Dutch end-users, as they are more comfortable to discuss and negotiate prices.
Price negotiating is less common in the UK
In the UK, we can note the lowest percentage of mechanical installers that are forced to negotiate prices with end-users due to online price checking. However, the lowest needs to be put in perspective, as close to half of all UK installers are still faced with having to negotiate with end-users.
The share of installers doesn’t paint the full picture
Even tough 60% of the European installers indicated that they are faced with price negotiation, this is only in 32% of their projects. Obviously, not all projects will contain products that are to be installed and worth the price checking effort. It is typically done more when the products involved are more expensive like boilers. Furthermore, checking of prices online and then trying to negotiate prices is more likely to be stronger in the B2C side of the business then in the B2B side.
What will the future hold?
One thing is for sure, despite the best efforts of the industry, price transparency is here to stay. Furthermore, as web shops become more internationalised, country specific price strategies will become even more difficult to maintain. Markets with higher prices might become under pressure from web shops operating in countries where the prices are lower. I think the installers can be sure that this phenomenon is here to stay and that it will increase further. This will put pressure on the price strategy of the entire business value chain, as installers in turn will try to negotiate better prices with the wholesale who in turn will look towards the manufacturers for better prices.
Of course the installers do have a position of relative power towards the end-user. In many countries the workload and orderbook of mechanical installers is still high, despite the corona crisis. Furthermore, the green transition will increase the orderbook and workload of installers even more. This could lead to a more take-it-or-leave-it attitude. Or prices are lowered, but higher labour costs are charged in order to keep the margins healthy.
If the corona crisis will start to impact the installers more severely, they could be forced to agree on lower prices and perhaps even end-users who buy the products themselves and only want to hire the labour.
I think the best bet would be to help the installers explain why their prices are higher then the lowest googled price. The added value they bring and why they charge more for this. Prices will inevitably become more transparent and uniform in Europe, but installers could still make a healthy margin on the products they install, if they are able to communicate why they charge more than the rock bottom lowest internet price.
Did COVID affect Contractors’ purchasing behaviour
Did COVID affect Contractors’ purchasing behaviour? For over a year now, the pandemic has had a huge... Read more
How effective are advertisements aimed at installers?
The question is whether electrical installers, arguably a major target audience of these advertisements, ac... Read more
Growth in architects’ BIM usage slower than expected
Growth in architects’ BIM usage slower than expected In 2019, usage of Building Information Modell... Read more